Pamela MaldonadoOct 19, 2025, 01:45 PM ETClosePamela Maldonado is a sports betting analyst for ESPN.Follow on X
Finebaum: Alabama has separated itself in the SEC (1:17)Paul Finebaum and Heather Dinich share why they have Alabama as their top team in the SEC. (1:17)
I expected all the problems we saw early — protection issues, lack of run identity, inconsistency on the road — to be major roadblocks. I thought those flaws would linger and cost them in the SEC grind, which is why I pegged them to miss the playoff.
But they have done what elite programs do: adapt, evolve and rise. And now, the Crimson Tide are the rightful favorites to win the conference.
Defensively, the Tide have cleaned up everything that went wrong early. The front seven is not vintage Alabama, but the coverage unit has locked in, keeping opponents under 7 yards per pass since Week 1. They are winning third downs, forcing turnovers and staying composed in pressure spots.
The biggest shift, however, is in discipline. Penalties dropped, turnovers disappeared and time of possession flipped from barely 29 minutes in the opener to nearly 36 through October. That is the sign of a mature football team.
This is not the same Alabama I was betting against in August. This is a team that rediscovered its core identity: efficient, composed, opportunistic. What started as a stumble has turned into a climb. At 6-1, Alabama is firmly part of the playoff conversation.
Georgia still has the better front seven and a steadier run game, but its offense lacks the vertical punch Alabama now leans on. Texas A&M, meanwhile, has shown flashes, but the defensive splits and inconsistencies against top competition reveal a ceiling that sits just below Alabama’s.
The Tide may have rebuilt themselves from that Week 1 loss, and they are absolutely a contender for the Playoff, but I am not ready to put them in the national title conversation. The run defense and lack of dominance in the trenches are still concerns. A true national title contender controls the line of scrimmage against elite teams, and Alabama is not quite there.
That opening loss to Florida State felt like confirmation of every preseason doubt; 17 points, eight penalties, no rhythm. But since then, Alabama has rebuilt itself piece by piece into something sharper and steadier. Quarterback Ty Simpson has gone from cautious to commanding, averaging 8.5 yards per attempt over his past four games against solid competition. The offense is balanced, explosive and efficient and has found its rhythm, buoyed by a run game that has caught up enough to sustain drives.
Finebaum: Alabama has separated itself in the SEC (1:17)Paul Finebaum and Heather Dinich share why they have Alabama as their top team in the SEC. (1:17)
Which brings us to the bigger picture: how Alabama stacks up in the SEC.
Paul Finebaum and Heather Dinich share why they have Alabama as their top team in the SEC. (1:17)
ClosePamela Maldonado is a sports betting analyst for ESPN.Follow on X